Seriously, their reds NEVER disappoint. I would pick up another red matte lip stick every few orders and since they are on sale and apparently discontinuing their entire line of lip products I figured I'd better complete the lineup!
After 5 falls in between You Red My Mind and Vampy. It's a deeper red than the former but not as deep as the latter. I think it has a different undertone than Vampy too, Vampy has this almost brownish/purple hue and After 5 feels more true deep red. Great for a more toned down, but still very red lip. I LOVE You Red My Mind but sometimes it seems a little much after 5. ;)
