Five stars because I don't dock points based on personal preference. The polish itself is lovely, and builds very slowly which I like. I am cool toned and thought this was a much cooler brown based on the photos. It would look so nice on me if I were just a bit warmer. Instead, regrettably, it looks like my fingernails picked up a 30-year smoking habit once I'm at the opacity I'd like. Would love a cooler brown or even just a blue-tinted topper to throw over this. (Or red, if I'm here making requests, but this one doesn't have anything to do with my review.)